Troperiffic Tuesday!: Deconstruction

Chick 1 says:

I have a friend who is an engineer.  When he was a child, he took apart a telephone just to see how it worked.  That is a great example of what the Deconstruction trope is all about.  We take apart a trope, a character, a genre, or even a series to see what makes it tick.  Or what would happen if we did…this?  

Deconstruction is an idea that is used in many disciplines besides storytelling but the goal is the same; to gain a better understanding of something by disassembling it. One of the most popular types of narrative Deconstruction is to ask what would happen to this trope, character or plot device if the rules of Real Life applied to it.  As Deconstruction often, not always, comes across as darker it can sometimes be interpreted as an attack on whatever is being deconstructed.   But it can give us a better understanding of how things work and an even bigger appreciation for tropes, characters, and stories we already love. 

One of my favorite Deconstructions is an episode of  Doctor Who called Midnight.  In this episode, the Doctor is stranded with a small group of tourists on a shuttle when an unknown force begins to attack.  This is where the Doctor would normally step up and save the day, winning the gratitude of those he rescues. But things don’t go very well for him.  

For starters, he is minus his human companion.  The Doctor almost always has a human companion to stand in for the audience (“Don’t try to follow along; just nod when he pauses for breath.”) and sometimes lampshade tropes (“He saves planets, rescues civilizations, defeats terrible creatures, … and runs a lot. Seriously, there’s an outrageous amount of running involved.”).  But take away his human companion and the cracks begin to show. Without someone to say, “This guy really is alright,”  (and no corridors to run down) all of the characteristics that make the Doctor who he is, his wit, his intelligence, his confidence, his belief that all life is valuable, and above all his belief that humans when encouraged will do the right thing work against him.   He comes across as arrogant and as he tries to ignite excitement among the group that they have discovered a new lifeform, the fearful tourists become more hostile.  Even his quirky use of the alias John Smith comes back to bite him in the butt.  By the end of the episode he is very nearly killed by his beloved humans. Instead of the normal upbeat ending, the story ends with the Doctor shell shocked and broken.

The episode is a fantastic Deconstruction of the Doctor himself as trope after trope that makes him a hero turn him into a villain in the eyes of the other passengers.  It was even a bit of a Deconstruction of head writer Russell Davies who tended to write villians that were very campy and moustache-twirling.  But in Midnight we not only never see the threat, we never find out what it was at all.  That type of freakiness is more characteristic of current head writer Stephen Moffat.

It could seem that in an age when audiences want more realism (or certain types of realism) that Deconstructions have become more popular.  But really every generation creates their own Decontructions of tropes and stories that they love.

The Great Gatsby is a Deconstruction of the American dream and the lavish lifestyle of The Roaring Twenties.

One could argue that Batman, especially Christopher Nolan’s movies, is a Deconstruction of Superman and other super heroes.  And Watchmen deconstructs the entire genre.

There’s a great Simpson’s episode that asks the question “How would a real-life person respond to Homer’s idiocy?”  The writers introduce Frank Grimes (or Grimey as he liked to be called) who eventually goes insane and dies.

The Shrek franchise is a Deconstruction of the fairy tale genre and Ever After takes a look at how Cinderella would play out without the magic, with Leonardo Di Vinci as her fairy godmother no less!

 So what Deconstructions helped you see in a new light?

Posted on by Chick 1 in Tropes 132 Comments

132 Responses to Troperiffic Tuesday!: Deconstruction

  1. Awinitabrorb

    Nicely put, With thanks!
    $10 min deposit online aus casinos online casino bitcoin casino roulette games online free

  2. Awinitabrorb

    Nicely put. Thank you!
    best casino slot games online free online casino slots cepheus star casino online real money login

  3. Awinitabrorb

    Lovely postings. Thanks a lot.
    casino essentials online training us online casinos online casino mit eu lizenz

  4. GilleskaM

    Very good info. Cheers.
    casino online deutsch online casino list gta online casino heist diamonds

  5. Willieerere

    Fine facts. Thanks.
    canada drugs coupon https://northwestpharmacylabs.com/ methylphenidate online pharmacy

  6. Willieerere

    Useful stuff. Cheers!

  7. StephanFloap

    Cheers, A lot of data.
    disartation writing essays services websites for essay writing

  8. IsmaelCax

    It’s awesome to go to see this site and reading the views of all friends concerning this article, while I am also eager of getting know-how.

    https://odegka-ua.com/vstanovlennya-mask-dlya-linz-3-dyuima-pokrokova-instruktsiya

  9. AscottThark

    Kudos! A lot of knowledge!
    36 red online casino no deposit online casino bonus wcasino online casino

  10. Sabahvab

    Thanks a lot! I like this.
    online casino laws brand new online casinos usa no deposit bonus codes redeemable freeplay online casino

  11. AlvaUnsew

    Great posts. Thank you.
    rivers philadelphia online casino online live casino best new online casinos with no deposit bonuses

  12. Macksodia

    Incredible a good deal of useful info!
    bitplay online casino casinos online no deposit usa friendly online casinos

  13. Lyneleds

    You made your stand pretty nicely!!
    888 casino online free top rated online casinos online gambling vs casino

  14. Elmirapen

    Nicely put, Appreciate it!
    2022 best online casino usa online casino vegas casino online io

  15. Elmirapen

    Many thanks! An abundance of info.
    online casino loyalty programs online casino in usa what states allow online casinos

  16. CandideOxync

    Truly many of wonderful material.
    australian online casino no deposit signup bonus best online casinos that payout usa how to collect winnings from online casino

  17. Mindyemact

    Many thanks! I value it.
    online casino license usa new usa online casinos with no deposit bonuses vegas william hill online casino

  18. Breccutext

    Thanks a lot. A lot of posts!
    zar casinos online online casino deposit bonus big daddy casino online login

  19. Breccutext

    With thanks. Great information!
    regulated online casino online american casinos slot casino gratis online

  20. Etilkapiz

    Nicely put. With thanks!
    free promo codes for online casinos casino usa online leovegas casino online in malta

  21. Huntlymip

    Kudos, A good amount of forum posts.
    real money online casino in pennsylvania brand new online casinos usa wyoming online casino

  22. Sinaibes

    Nicely put, With thanks!
    create online casino casino games online free legit online casinos canada

  23. Sinaibes

    This is nicely expressed. !
    admiral club casino online free casinos online vegas casino online no deposit codes

  24. AscottThark

    Kudos! Numerous postings!
    online baccarat casino online live casino casino review online

  25. Fifibit

    Wonderful knowledge. Thanks a lot.
    firefrog online casino us online casino online usa casino no deposit bonus

  26. Fifibit

    Incredible all kinds of helpful advice!
    jackpot city com online casino best online casino usa gun lake casino online games

  27. Martydah

    Excellent material. Thanks a lot.
    online casinos that really pay online usa casinos bally’s casino online nj

  28. CandideOxync

    Superb information. Regards.
    free online vegas casino games popular online casinos spin palace juegos de casino online

  29. Etilkapiz

    Thanks. Fantastic stuff!
    free casino games online to play without downloading new online casinos online casino india no deposit bonus

  30. Etilkapiz

    Nicely put, Regards!
    gambling online casinos bet online casino online casino deposit with credit card

  31. Huntlymip

    You suggested this fantastically.
    casino bet online bd best usa online casino lucky north casino online

  32. Saharaphype

    You mentioned that perfectly!
    sverige online casino casino online no deposit bonus tao online casino

Add a Comment