Troperiffic Tuesday!: One Steve Limit

Chick 1 says:

This week’s trope is once again an example of how the world of fiction often doesn’t (and possibly shouldn’t) mirror the real world.  Ever notice how in most books, TV shows, and movies no one has the same name?  But in the real world people share first, last, or both names all the time.  There is a very important reason that it doesn’t happen often in fiction; it’s confusing.

When you are creating a story and the universe in which your characters will live, everything is completely new to your audience, even if the plot takes place in modern day America.  And there are a lot of details to keep track of.  Having two characters with the same name or even similar sounding names, even if it is more realistic, will just muddy the waters. (Anyone else wonder in Lord of the Rings if they were talking about Sauron or Saruman?)  Thus almost all fictional works have a One Steve Limit.

This trope is so prevalent that it’s easier to point out exceptions instead of examples.  Having two characters share a name is usually used for comedy although it can be played for drama as in The Two Jakes or The Big Lebowski, in which a case of mistaken identity sets off the entire plot.  Inside Man subverted this trope by having all the bank robbers go by some form of Steve. (Yes, they actually picked “Steve” as their common name.)  A common name was one of the characteristics of the ruling clique in the movie Heathers, although this could be considered an example of the subtrope Planet of Steves, where a common name is used to demonstrate lack of individuality or personal freedom.

On a lighter note,  we have the classic from Newhart. “I’m Larry. This is my brother Daryl.  This is my other brother Daryl.”  Made all the sillier in that it’s not just coincidence; their parents actually gave them the same name.

An episode of Doctor Who encountered a group with two Daves.  They went by Proper Dave and Other Dave.  Neither fared very well in the adventure.

The clever title of The New Adventures of Old Christine uses a subversion of this trope when the titular character’s ex-husband marries another woman names Christine.  See how confusing that can be?

 

Posted on by Chick 1 in Tropes 205 Comments

205 Responses to Troperiffic Tuesday!: One Steve Limit

  1. Belindaatomi

    Nicely expressed really. !
    sloto cash casino online https://usacasinomaster.com/poker-apps/ royal vegas casino online

  2. Belindaatomi

    Cheers! Good stuff!
    cГЎc trang casino online uy tГ­n https://usacasinomaster.com/indiana-casinos/ online casinos mit dragonfish

  3. Belindaatomi

    Really a lot of awesome advice.
    mejores casinos online en argentina https://usacasinomaster.com/live-casinos/ casino royale online for free

  4. Belindaatomi

    You expressed this superbly!
    online casino pay paypal https://uscasinoguides.com/poker-real-money/ real online casinos that pay cash

  5. Belindaatomi

    Very good content. Regards!
    online casino download free https://usagamblinghub.com/cricket-betting/ how to open online casino business

  6. Belindaatomi

    You actually stated it effectively.
    deck media online casinos https://usagamblinghub.com/colorado-casinos/ casino online mr green

  7. Belindaatomi

    You made your point pretty clearly!!
    how to know if an online casino is legitimate https://usagamblinghub.com/arizona-casinos/ gta online casino heist power drills

  8. Belindaatomi

    You’ve made your stand quite effectively..
    top five online casinos https://usacasinomaster.com/gambling-apps/ online casino bonus 200 prozent

  9. Belindaatomi

    You stated that wonderfully.
    best credit card casino online https://usacasinomaster.com/slotland-review/ casinos online sin licencia

  10. Belindaatomi

    You actually explained this adequately.
    online casinos gambling https://usagamblinghub.com/mybookie-review/ online casino with free bonus no deposit

  11. Belindaatomi

    Helpful forum posts. With thanks.
    casino royal club online casino https://uscasinoguides.com/canadian-casinos/ nieuwe online casino nederland

  12. Belindaatomi

    Amazing many of fantastic knowledge.
    casino online uk free spins no deposit https://usagamblinghub.com/nhl-betting/ casino the card game online

  13. Belindaatomi

    Effectively spoken certainly! .
    online casino italian https://usagamblinghub.com/massachusetts-casinos/ g pay online casino

  14. Belindaatomi

    Fine postings. Regards!
    gta online diamond casino heist points of interest https://usaplayerscasino.com/real-money-casinos/ die besten online casinos der welt

  15. Belindaatomi

    You actually expressed this wonderfully.
    gta v online casino heist best hacker https://usacasinomaster.com/ignition-review/ carding online casinos

  16. Belindaatomi

    Nicely put. Thank you!
    new online casinos canada no deposit bonus https://uscasinoguides.com/washington-casinos/ best la online casino

  17. Belindaatomi

    Great postings. With thanks.
    casino online vulkan vegas https://usacasinomaster.com/minnesota-casinos/ gta online casino replay glitch

  18. Belindaatomi

    Many thanks! Numerous postings!
    erfahrung online casino https://luckyusaplay.com/bitcoin-casinos/ online casino payout

  19. Belindaatomi

    Beneficial data. Thanks a lot!
    top online casinos bonus https://luckyusaplay.com/crypto-casinos/ beste gewinnchancen online casino

  20. Belindaatomi

    With thanks! I appreciate this.
    guru online casino https://usagamblinghub.com/bitcoin-casinos/ online casino jobs cyprus

  21. GilleskaM

    Nicely put. Thanks a lot!
    malta licensed online casinos new online casinos usa real money monopoly casino game online

  22. Buintondof

    Really quite a lot of very good tips!
    ruleta casino online simulador biggest online casino play craps free online casino

  23. BeadutunRef

    Thanks, Helpful stuff!
    online casino danske spil top rated online casinos online casino betting in kenya

  24. SewardRer

    Seriously all kinds of very good information.
    new jersey online casino promo code free casino games online bandar judi casino sic bo online

  25. HalimahPex

    Fine posts. Thanks a lot.
    what states have legal online casinos deposit bonus online casinos best online casino playtech

  26. Awinitabrorb

    Wow lots of great info!
    online gaming casinos biggest online casino crazy slots online casino

  27. Donogbrit

    Seriously lots of amazing information.
    free online casino games no download with bonus best online casino bonuses sugarhouse pa online casino & pa sportsbook

  28. HalimahPex

    Thanks a lot, An abundance of material.
    online casino promo codes pa new online usa casinos best casino games to make money online

  29. GilleskaM

    Many thanks. Lots of stuff.
    gw online casino casino online games easy online casino games

  30. Awinitabrorb

    Very good postings. With thanks!
    88 fortunes casino online best online usa casinos agent ligaz888 casino online

  31. Donogbrit

    Wonderful knowledge. Thanks!
    mgm casino online gambling best online casinos that payout va online casino

  32. Buintondof

    You mentioned that exceptionally well.
    888 online casino michigan online casino reviews top online casino in india

  33. SewardRer

    Perfectly expressed without a doubt! .
    gamble max casino online reviews new online casinos usa 888 casino online casino

  34. GilleskaM

    Kudos, Awesome information.
    como ganar en las mГЎquinas del casino online online casino bitcoin best online casino 2015

  35. Buintondof

    You made your point extremely nicely!!
    miami casino online new online casino usa ok hard rock casino online gambling florida

  36. BeadutunRef

    Nicely put, Appreciate it.
    online casino no deposit free play casino games online casino royale 2006 full movie online

  37. Olaflok

    Awesome advice. Cheers.
    bingo online casinos best online casino reddit no deposit bonus ainsworth gaming technology online casinos

  38. HalimahPex

    Kudos! I enjoy this.
    iowa casino online online casino free spins vegas paradise online casino

  39. Quentfaups

    This is nicely put! !
    online casino accepting australian players best online us casinos casino slots online no deposit

  40. GilleskaM

    Thank you! Loads of info.
    real money online usa casinos best online us casinos online casino sites usa

  41. Awinitabrorb

    Superb advice. Thanks!
    bandar judi casino bluebet33 online no deposit online casino usa best online casinos norway

  42. Donogbrit

    Thanks! Lots of facts.
    casino dealer training online free online casinos lucky nugget free online casino

  43. CiprianaObjef

    You made the point.
    unibet pa online casino new online casinos usa real money borgata casino online apk

  44. Buintondof

    Many thanks. Numerous posts!
    best online casinos.com play online casino 777casino online casino

  45. Olaflok

    You actually explained that well.
    online casinos with daily bonus casino games online best new online casinos 2017

  46. BeadutunRef

    Terrific information. Cheers!
    william hill casino online uk online casino gaming tu casino online

  47. HalimahPex

    Really plenty of wonderful data!
    online casino welcome bonus 100 biggest online casino online casino india legal

  48. Quentfaups

    Thank you. Numerous knowledge!
    casino night online online casino free spins amazon wild online casinos

  49. GilleskaM

    Good posts. Cheers.
    slot guard online casino online casino free bonus top 5 online casinos

  50. Awinitabrorb

    Valuable forum posts. Many thanks.
    stream casino movie online casinos online usa online casino nh

Add a Comment