Troperiffic Tuesday!: One Steve Limit

Chick 1 says:

This week’s trope is once again an example of how the world of fiction often doesn’t (and possibly shouldn’t) mirror the real world.  Ever notice how in most books, TV shows, and movies no one has the same name?  But in the real world people share first, last, or both names all the time.  There is a very important reason that it doesn’t happen often in fiction; it’s confusing.

When you are creating a story and the universe in which your characters will live, everything is completely new to your audience, even if the plot takes place in modern day America.  And there are a lot of details to keep track of.  Having two characters with the same name or even similar sounding names, even if it is more realistic, will just muddy the waters. (Anyone else wonder in Lord of the Rings if they were talking about Sauron or Saruman?)  Thus almost all fictional works have a One Steve Limit.

This trope is so prevalent that it’s easier to point out exceptions instead of examples.  Having two characters share a name is usually used for comedy although it can be played for drama as in The Two Jakes or The Big Lebowski, in which a case of mistaken identity sets off the entire plot.  Inside Man subverted this trope by having all the bank robbers go by some form of Steve. (Yes, they actually picked “Steve” as their common name.)  A common name was one of the characteristics of the ruling clique in the movie Heathers, although this could be considered an example of the subtrope Planet of Steves, where a common name is used to demonstrate lack of individuality or personal freedom.

On a lighter note,  we have the classic from Newhart. “I’m Larry. This is my brother Daryl.  This is my other brother Daryl.”  Made all the sillier in that it’s not just coincidence; their parents actually gave them the same name.

An episode of Doctor Who encountered a group with two Daves.  They went by Proper Dave and Other Dave.  Neither fared very well in the adventure.

The clever title of The New Adventures of Old Christine uses a subversion of this trope when the titular character’s ex-husband marries another woman names Christine.  See how confusing that can be?

 

Posted on by Chick 1 in Tropes 205 Comments

205 Responses to Troperiffic Tuesday!: One Steve Limit

  1. CiprianaObjef

    You’ve made your point pretty effectively.!
    online casino bets best online casino bonuses rsweeps online casino 777 download for iphone

  2. Buintondof

    You said it perfectly.!
    palm casino online new online casino online casino fruit

  3. Olaflok

    You said it perfectly..
    best gaming1 online casinos online casino welcome bonus online casino paraguay

  4. BeadutunRef

    Amazing posts. Many thanks!
    online casino real money oklahoma casino online usa best ca bgaming online casinos

  5. HalimahPex

    Nicely put. Thanks.
    online casino uk free bonus online casinos with no deposit bonus mega casino online

  6. Quentfaups

    Appreciate it! Loads of facts.
    deutsch online casino online american casinos online casino bonus gegenГјberstellung

  7. GilleskaM

    Cheers, I value it.
    nj casino online gambling sites best online casinos that payout online casino spelen nederland

  8. Donogbrit

    Appreciate it. Lots of information.
    jackpot city online casino australia new online usa casinos casino cz online

  9. CiprianaObjef

    Fantastic info. Regards!
    online com casino casino online free casino online 1500

  10. Buintondof

    Seriously a good deal of amazing knowledge.
    free cash no deposit online casino online casino bonus codes melhor casino online para ganhar dinheiro

  11. Olaflok

    Fine content. Kudos!
    best real online casino app best paying online casino fatbet casino online

  12. BeadutunRef

    Regards. A good amount of information!
    online casino synonym casino online bonus sweeps cash casinos online

  13. SewardRer

    Appreciate it. Numerous facts.
    mohegan sun online casino free online casino no deposit bonus codes allwilds online casinos

  14. Quentfaups

    Whoa lots of wonderful facts!
    sg online casino us online casinos with rtg software is mr beast’s online casino real

  15. GilleskaM

    Very well voiced certainly! !
    online casino mit handy einzahlen online usa casinos online jackpot city casino

  16. Donogbrit

    Well spoken certainly. .
    nj bally casino online social casinos online best online casinos for real money 2023

  17. Buintondof

    Nicely put, Thank you.
    mohegan sun casino online ct casino game online glory casino online login

  18. BeadutunRef

    Seriously tons of beneficial tips!
    las vegas casinos games free online free casino online mexico online casinos

  19. Olaflok

    With thanks! I enjoy this.
    yonkers casino online online casino bonus e games online casino

  20. GilleskaM

    Thank you. I appreciate this.
    120 free spins online casino legit best online casino mentor online casino website design

  21. Awinitabrorb

    You actually mentioned that exceptionally well!
    casino online bonus benvenuto senza deposito casino games online for real money parx online casino bonus

  22. Awinitabrorb

    Valuable postings. Many thanks.
    crocs online casino online usa casinos agen casino slot joker123 online

  23. Awinitabrorb

    You reported it really well.
    online casinos zonder nederlandse vergunning online casino with virtual reality gaming experiences bandar casino joker123 online

  24. Awinitabrorb

    Factor very well considered.!
    mega jackpot online casino slot online casino casino blackjack online free

  25. Awinitabrorb

    Nicely put. Thanks!
    juegos online casino best canadian online casino online casino real money in india

  26. Awinitabrorb

    Appreciate it! A lot of write ups.
    5 dollar deposit casinos online games casino free online neu online casino

  27. Awinitabrorb

    You stated it exceptionally well.
    los mejores casinos online de espaГ±a canadian casino online casino gambling legal

  28. Awinitabrorb

    Whoa tons of useful material.
    free spins no deposit online casino online real casino online casino black jack

  29. Awinitabrorb

    Really many of superb data.
    online casino croatia best online casino slot machines casino svizzera online

  30. Awinitabrorb

    Superb postings. Thanks a lot!
    247 online casino casino online canada best promo codes for online casinos

  31. Awinitabrorb

    Kudos! Lots of tips!
    vegas rio casino online login online casino with real money casino online sign up bonus

  32. Awinitabrorb

    This is nicely expressed. .
    hollywood online casino reviews slot machine online casino mgm grand casino online betting

  33. Awinitabrorb

    Terrific stuff. Thank you!
    ndb codes for online casinos online casino real money no deposit popular online casino games

  34. Awinitabrorb

    Fantastic data. Kudos.
    pala casino online michigan las vegas online casino real money rsweeps online casino 777 for iphone

  35. Awinitabrorb

    With thanks, Ample information!
    918kisss online casino casino slots free online juegos de casino online gratis en espaГ±ol sin descargar

  36. Awinitabrorb

    Helpful advice. Thank you.
    best online casino uae free slot machines casino online slots games west virginia online casino bonuses

  37. Awinitabrorb

    You actually mentioned this exceptionally well.
    nj online casino blackjack online casino real money free all online casinos nj

  38. Awinitabrorb

    You mentioned it effectively.
    777 casino play online slot casino online best online sweeps casino

  39. Awinitabrorb

    You said it perfectly.!
    banküberweisung seriöse online casinos usa casino online casino slot games free online

  40. Awinitabrorb

    Many thanks, I appreciate this!
    online casinos in arizona slots online casino online casino dansk777

  41. GilleskaM

    Whoa plenty of excellent tips.
    casino online dinosaur game newest online casinos usa live casino games online free

  42. Willieerere

    You said it exceptionally well!
    king soopers pharmacy https://northwestpharmacylabs.com/ canada pet pharmacy

  43. GilleskaM

    Awesome info. Cheers.
    online casino games in the philippines online casino free spins no deposit mejores casinos online peru

  44. Willieerere

    Reliable stuff. Thank you!

  45. Willieerere

    With thanks! Useful stuff.

  46. StephanFloap

    Truly a lot of valuable information.
    best college application essay ever write essays for me personal essay college application

  47. StephanFloap

    Reliable knowledge. With thanks!
    legal dissertation essay writer custom essay writing service toronto

  48. best crypto casinos uk

    I couldn’t refrain from commenting. Perfectly written!

  49. best real money casino usa

    It is truly a great and useful piece of info. I am glad that you simply shared this helpful info with us.
    Please stay us up to date like this. Thank you for
    sharing.

  50. nj online casinos

    I’m not sure why but this site is loading very slow for me.
    Is anyone else having this issue or is it a problem on my end?
    I’ll check back later on and see if the problem still exists.

Add a Comment